This was originally posted on May 30, 2013, but there sadly is a need to get some things clear in our collective conscious!

Since Anthony Weiner is back (again!) in the news, I thought it good to reflect some on his undoing.

Let’s get things clear from the get go.  I find Weiner’s behavior inexcusable and to employ a word I have not yet heard: sinful.

It is a good thing Weiner resigned from the Congress.  The spectacle that preceded it was unfortunate.  It only seemed to underscore the very problem that got Weiner into trouble to begin with, namely his narcissistic tendency toward self-promotion.  As some preachers I’ve heard proclaim, “Sometimes we have got to repent of our repentance.”

It is interesting to hear the commentary by the media and members of Congress, but not so much for what has been said.  Rather, it is what was left unsaid that has been striking.

For example, why are so many up in arms over what Weiner did?  If there is no God, as Dostoyevsky famously declared, then all things are permissible.  I imagine there are several in the media and in Congress who find the “fear of the Lord” a quaint maxim of a bygone era.  Nevertheless they are quick to pronounce absolute judgment on Weiner.  No one seems troubled by this inconsistency.

For those of us who do believe in the “fear of the Lord” it is crucial to do some honest soul-searching.  Sure, our sins may not be public.  They may also occur in more socially respectable areas of life: food instead of sex, gossip instead of hubris, and lying instead of lying.  Wait a second.  We are more like Weiner than we care to admit!

As a Christian, I believe God can redeem anyone.  The death and resurrection of Jesus takes the hideousness of sin and the hope-filled reality of a changed life seriously.  The Bible is loaded with unsavory characters who found redemption.  King David was a murderer and adulterer.  And yes, King David also lied.   He outdid Weiner on many fronts.

One’s understanding of redemption in the Christian sense starts by recognizing our real problem: sin.  Failure to appreciate our own sin results in simply casting stones at fellow human beings.  Instead of seeing redemption as a real possibility we gladly cast the pariah to the margins of society.  With the offending party gone from our midst we are freed from having to ponder our own compulsions, dysfunctions, hubris, self-satisfaction, arrogance, and what can be the umbrella term for all: sin. 

When a society loses the language to depict the realities of sin, it has lost more than it can possibly know.  When sin is gone from the scene, so is redemption.  And when redemption is gone, where does that leave us?


  1. jim

    I have no desire to cast stones at Weiner. I suppose what makes his “behavior inexcusable” is that a public figure should have more “public” self-control over his morality (or maybe not these days). Or maybe his public tweeting and thinking it wouldn’t get out shows he just isn’t savvy enough to be a good big city mayor.

  2. Jeannie Love

    If we take our Christian beliefs seriously, you are indeed right on point. As a result, we DO know sin ‘looks’ many different ways. To not believe or name sin, we just revert to a type of ‘degree’ of wrong doing–some bother us more than others. “Amazing grace, how sweet the sound, that saved a WRETCH like me.”

  3. Clover

    I hope that one day brokenness and humility make Weiner a prayerful man of God that would draw others to his redemption through Christ. However this does not mean that as Christians we should be silent politically. As some modern scholars have pointed out; human governments have been deciding what is best for human flourishing for a long time. We Christians as American citizens still have the right to vote for who we think will best lead our country in the direction we think is best. We might not be in the popular view but since when has popularity decided what is true or right. Our task as Christians is to not let self-righteousness be our idol. By the way…I am a wretched sinner and I vote.

  4. jim

    And let me add – I thank God at least every other day there was no social media devices when I was in high school, college, most of my twenties – or I would be unemployable in any sort of ministry today. Anthony should have gained more worldly wisdom from his years.

  5. Pingback: Weekly Meanderings

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *