Category Archives: Civil War

GETTYSBURG DID NOT END THE WAR

It is commonly thought that the Battle of Gettysburg ended the war.  The eminent Civil War historian, Gary Gallagher, disagrees:

Gallagher’s argument began with an explanation of what he called “Appomattox Syndrome” — a complex in which historians study an event or era beginning with the end. (“Appomattox” references the courthouse where the Confederacy surrendered, bringing the Civil War to an end.) Gallagher said that this method of studying history is wrong because history didn’t happen backwards.

“Read forward in the evidence and you will find complexity and contingency far beyond what that other way of looking in the past allows you to find,” Gallagher said. “Do not ever start at the end in order to understand what happened if your goal is to understand how it unfolded.”

By studying the Civil War from the beginning, and from a historical point of view rather than relying only on memories, he said, it becomes very obvious that neither the Battles of Gettysburg or Vicksburg nor the year 1863 had very much to do with turning the tide of the war.

The rest of the article is here:

http://chqdaily.com/2013/07/10/gallagher-gettysburg-vicksburg-are-flashy-but-clearly-not-civil-wars-turning-points/

On the same subject, you can experience Gallagher’s engaging and informed style here:

GREAT HISTORY FROM A MASTER

Allen Guelzo is well-known for his many contributions to Lincoln scholarship and related topics.

Fateful Lightning showcases Guelzo’s beautiful writing along with his keen eye for capturing the telling details. I have not read James McPherson’s survey of the Civil War, so I am not able to compare it with Guelzo’s. Allen Guelzo has certainly produced a fine a piece of work which those wanting an authoritative overview will get by reading Fateful Lightning.

IS THE CIVIL WAR MORE EXCITING TO STUDY THAN THE BIBLE?

Listen to this one minute of excitement (starts at 21:30) about the endless riches of the Civil War.  Professor Gary Gallagher, an eminent scholar of the Civil War, is unashamed to gush about how thrilling it is to study the Civlil War.

Why do so many of us not have this level of enthusiasm when it comes to studying the Bible?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8Tm5aXS22o

WAR IS HELL

African Americans picking up bones of Civil War dead

Columbia professor, Andrew Delbanco, has memorably said, “Before the Civil War people believed in the providence of God.  After the war, they believed in luck.”

Ambrose Bierce is best known for his satirical work, The Devil’s Dictionary.  He experienced the brutal fighting at the Battle of Shiloh.

Allen Guelzo in his fine new book, Fateful Lightning, mentions a soldier who was “shot in the head but still alive.”  Guelzo proceeds to add the graphic and oft quoted observation Bierce supplied of the scene.  Here is just a bit:

“…taking in his breath in convulsive, rattling snorts, and blowing it out in sputters of froth which crawled creamily down his cheeks…”

There is a lot of reality to process when it comes to horrific events like the Civil War.  As Christians, we need to be ready to offer thoughtful, compassionate, and honest reflections to life’s most vexing issues.